advertisement

SSN on Facebook SSN on Twitter SSN on YouTube RSS Feed

8 Comments
Columns

Shameful Spending Part of an Abusive Union Relationship

March 20, 2019 - 9:00am
It’s time to stop applauding the efforts of union-funded special interests -- masquerading as “teachers” --- working to deny students the opportunity to pursue their dreams. 
 
We all have fond memories of a teacher who changed our lives. The FEA knows this and is exploiting our love for teachers to bully legislators and suppress the will of families for one reason: MONEY. Specifically, the money they collect from hard-working Florida teachers. Now they are using this money to run a self-proclaimed “six figure campaign” against Florida families.
 
This is shameful.
 
The union is engaged in psychological warfare and willing to sacrifice the best interests of children in the process. They use words like “diverting, funneling, and siphoning,” as though the money belongs to them and is not generated to educate students.
 
The union calls for “fully funding” public education and then sets up a false narrative that students who chose a non-union school are depleting resources.
 
Funding levels are the highest they have ever been in Florida and the results of reforms demonstrate that Florida education is improving. 
 
Do they consider it “draining” resources when a student moves to a neighboring county? Mass migrations for employment happen when a new major employer creates jobs, and districts adjust by scaling back expenses. It’s not “draining,” it is moving. 
 
When money follows the student, the student is served. Public schools are funded by the state based on how many students they serve. The money follows the child to the school, because the child creates the demand for resources -- supplies, teachers, space, etc. The presence or lack of choice schools doesn’t add or subtract funding from traditional public schools. In fact, some research shows a benefit because when students leave for choice schools, their former public schools continue receiving their full allocation of local and federal dollars, meaning increased per-pupil funding for those students who stay.
 
But to the unions, parents who don’t choose employers (schools and their teachers) within their membership are “diverting” funds from public schools. Again, the union is focused on the funds. Funds. Funds! What about the children? 
 
We see through this. 
 
For a parent, “diverting” a child from a zoned school can mean diverting a child from failure, stagnation, bullying or prison, and “funneling” the child into a life of success, purpose and met needs.
 
A recent study suggests that school choice programs reduce drug arrests and  teen pregnancy, and another study demonstrates that students on these programs not only attend college at higher rates, but also graduate at higher rates. These programs are literally helping make dreams come true.
 
Most public school teachers aren’t told they don’t have to join the union, as they are ushered into paying more than $600 annually in union dues, more than lawyers pay for their Bar dues. The teachers who teach in charter and private schools aren’t union dues-paying members, but they are still part of an honorable profession. Our complaint isn’t with teachers, it’s with the union thugs who want to hold children hostage for their per-pupil funding.
 
Instead of waging psychological warfare against the dreams of children and the rights of families, the union could use that “six figure” advertising spend -- comprised of teachers’ hard-earned money -- to buy supplies for the classroom to help teachers be more effective without taxing their personal accounts. 
 
They won’t. Do you know why? Because it won’t help them increase the money in their membership dues account. 
 
The union doesn’t work for students, and they barely work for teachers. It’s an abusive relationship where they want to control the checkbook, telling teachers what to think and blaming “outsiders” for the problems in their relationship. 
 
The war the union is waging on non-union schools is an effort to grow union dues by eliminating competition. They don’t care who is harmed in the process. 
 
Let’s “siphon” the negative campaigning against the aspirations of children, and “divert” power to parents to represent their children’s needs. Let’s put students first. 
 
There is more at stake than money. Lives are at stake. Children can’t write checks, so there won’t be a major “six-figure ad spend” to fight for their freedom. But we can and will use our voices. 
 
It’s time to release the students being held hostage for their per-pupil funding and let educational freedom ring.
 
Shawn Frost is a former public school science teacher, managing member of MVP Strategy and Policy, LLC, former Indian River County School Board member, School Choice Movement board member, as well as founder and past president of the Florida Coalition of School Board Members.

Comments

What are you talking about?? We have to have a counterbalance to the tear up the public school system - give everyone a voucher hysteria that is gripping this state. If you think our school system has problems now wait until there is no school boards and there are small storefront schools everywhere - and none of them are accountable to anyone. You will see state capital improvement dollars evaporate into private pockets when these schools close their doors - leaving parents with no alternatives for educating their children. It will be worse in low income areas where the public schools are floundering for neglect.

Florida teacher unions are a joke. National education and labor publications have consistently ranked them as the weakest in the US. The fact Florida is 46 th in teacher pay is a direct correlation of the lack of power Florida teacher unions enjoy. In other words, they couldn’t negotiate themselves out of a wet paper bag. Unions exist only for union officers and staffers to make six figure salaries while shipping most local dues to the lackluster state and national unions. That’s why the majority of Florida teacher unions are barely above 50% membership . Even half of all teachers want nothing to do with them.

What Shawn Frost is talking about is tax vouchers going to private and religious schools. However, our Florida constitution already forbids this. It’s right there in Article 1 Section 3: “No revenue of the state or any political subdivision or agency thereof shall ever be taken from the public treasury directly or indirectly in aid of any church, sect, or religious denomination or in aid of any sectarian institution.“ Any reasonable person can see that tax credit vouchers are against our constitution, but the courts say that tax credits aren’t technically in the treasury, so it’s legal. It may be legal, but it’s not right. We need to stop it.

Unions of public employees should be outlawed. Whatever congressional Act allowed gov’t employees to unionize should be deleted. Instead, we need 360 degree evaluations to prevent unjust treatment and increase individual worker merit pay. It’s a lie to claim past unions “created the middle class” — a bald faced lie. Mass production, the GI Bill and college degrees did much more. Today unions are an archaic relic of the past, like the Mafia, and struggle to stay relevant by new ways of intimidation and lies. Luckily the federal gov’t began co-opting union benefits on behalf of all workers long ago. They’re no longer needed.

You scab bastards don’t give a rat’s behind about public schools or the kids who attend them. No teacher in his or her right mind would walk into a classroom without union protection.

What a revealing representative of unions you are.

Unions built the middle class and as unionization in this country shrunk so did the middle class. Furthermore unions are the reason why so many Americans have health care and retirement plans they can live on. Let’s be real the privitazation attempt of public education is about the profiteers and not the kids.

Unions were the reason why the United States developed a virbrant, expanding, and voluble middle class and unions were the progenitors of "The Great American Century" following WW II. The Republicans relentless effort to destroy unionism is why the new century's middle class is crumbling away to nothing (back to being 'serfs'?) and the "New Robber Barons" (the fatcat 'masters') are once again running the show as they did way back when ... until Republican Theodore Roosevelt put the brakes on them and reversed that ruinous circumstance. Time for working Americans to put forth a new, major effort to rebuild and re-strengthen unions!

Comments are now closed.

columns
advertisement
advertisement
advertisement
Live streaming of WBOB Talk Radio, a Sunshine State News Radio Partner.

advertisement
advertisement