advertisement

SSN on Facebook SSN on Twitter SSN on YouTube RSS Feed

3 Comments
Columns

Jeff Vinik Tax Just Doesn’t Add Up

September 5, 2018 - 6:00am

The 1 percent Jeff Vinik-inspired sales tax increase propaganda machine is up and running. The misinformation campaign has started. 

The director of the Hillsborough County MPO, Beth Alden, told the Tampa City Council what the 1 percent sales tax would pay for in the MPO 2040 Long Range Transportation Plan. She stated that the petition would increase the sales tax 1 percent for 30 years, then proceeded to read off a list of items in the 2040 plan as if they were 100 percent in sync.

It is true that both the 2040 MPO Plan and the Petition on the ballot in November are based on a 30-year, 1 percent sales tax hike, but the resemblance stops there. 

The differences are so glaring it calls into question Alden’s motives. Could it be because the Vinik Tax overfunds the MPO for research and planning by $74 million?  That’s quite a payoff!

That’s plenty of incentive for omissions.  There were plenty of ‘em.  Alden failed:

  • to present any math comparisons to the MPO board or the Tampa City Council. 
  • to mention the amount of money the MPO stated a 1% sales tax would raise. 
  • to state if the funding categories in the MPO 2040 plan were funded to the same amount from the funding restrictions placed in the Sales Tax Petition. 
  • to disclose what the “real” congestion relief will be with the tax. 
  • to explain what the CO2 emissions will be.

Alden did exactly what her All For Transportation puppet masters wanted: provide propaganda to sell the petition. Would she say the same things in court, on the stand and under oath?  We believe she would recant rather than perjure herself.

The current 2040 MPO transportation plan is based on a 1 percent sales tax, but extends only 22 years. In those 22 years the 1 percent sales tax raises $9 billion according to the MPO and County Administrator Mike Merrill. 

Let’s do some math.  All For Transportation and its supporters state it raises $280 million per year, period. The years 2019 to 2040 cover 22 years and 22 x 280 = $6.16 billion, just under $3 billion short of the MPO 2040 plan.

But why quibble over $3 billion?  Even using the $9 billion dollars the MPO states a 1% sales tax raises in 22 years, the AFT plan underfinances roads while overfinancing transit and MPO planning and development.

The first three subsections of the petition, 11.07 (1)(2)(3) are under financed by $69 million dollars. These sections deal with intersection improvement and flow, road vulnerability to disasters, maintenance of roads, and “congestion reduction.”  It would be illegal if any of these funds are used for new roads or widening roads unless they are fully funded which they are not. 

The fourth general purpose area for non-transit expenses, 11.07(4) Transportation Network Improvements states “ at least 12% of General Purpose Funds shall be extended on bicycle or pedestrian infrastructure and related improvements that make walking and biking safer”. This Section 11.07(4) is the only overfunded part of the General Purpose non-transit funds and is over funded by $259.85 million dollars.

Yes, bicycles and pedestrian improvements are over funded by $259 million. There are millions of dollars in possible bicycle and pedestrian improvements above the MPO 2040 Level 3 new funding, but this increases the funding by 80 percent.

There are billions of dollars in needed road widening and new roads not funded in the MPO 2040 plan.

The last sec 11.07(5) is titled “Remaining Funds” and may be spent on “any project to improve transportation”. Although road widening and new roads are never mentioned, this is the section that AFT members point to as being able to fund the “New Road Capacity” in the MPO 2040 plan. The 1 percent Sales Tax Petition Plan underfunds this category about $242 million, depending on the complete financing of a couple roads. 

Not a single penny of the tax goes to new roads or road widening in the county south of Bloomingdale Ave. If you live south of Bloomingdale Ave., you will pay the tax but not a penny goes to road widening or new roads. Because they underfunded “NEW ROAD CAPACITY” by so much, the MPO will need to eliminate 25% of the roads on the present 2040 plan and some roads to be built in South county by developer/mobility fee funding.

The transit portion of the 1% Sales Tax Petition overfunds the 3 transit sections. Yes, the All for Transportation 1 percent sales tax funding percentages overfund the transit portion by $600 million. The road capacity, new and widened, are underfunded by $242 million. 

The only thing that decreases the non-transit total portion deficit is the massive funding for bicycles and pedestrians.

The MPO section of the petition overfunds the MPO for research and planning by $74 million.

These are the numbers that can be validated on a cell phone calculator.  Alden must have left her phone at home the day she presented to the Tampa City Council. This misinformation campaign will be promoted by All for Transportation and the Tampa Bay Times for the next two months.

 “The Great Rail Robbery” will be a financial debacle. 

The congestion, environmental problems, displacement of minority communities, and quality of life issues with this Vinik Tax Plan will soon be made available to all voters but the bribed mainstream media won’t be the ones to present the real facts.

Voters need to confront elected officials and candidates over the next two months.  The electorate should demand these politicos take a stand against this crime.

  

Dr. Jim Davison is a conservative activist and noted expert on transit and tax matters. This column appears courtesy of The Tampa Bay Beat.

 


READ MORE FROM SUNSHINE STATE NEWS

Greed Over Need as Hillsborough Schools Go Begging: Thanks, Tampa Bay Times

Special Interests vs. The People: Hillsborough Tax War Has Officially Begun

Comments

I’m not in favor of the referendum and I’m a rail fan. But how does anyone, by any stretch of the imagination, thinks the transportation referendum is about building a rail line??? Rail costs $100+ Million a mile. This tax is going to raise $280 Million a year. In 30 years they will have enough to build about 50 miles of track what with cost increases through the years. People who think this is about rail need to go back to school and re-learn math.

Billionaires screwing taxpayers. The 'New America' and Trump 'Making America Great Again'. If Vinik and Sternberg want a transportation network to bring customers to their private profit-making projects in downtown Tampa - let them pay for it! (Same with Sternberg's stadium!)

This scam is about rail for the stadium. It is indeed a robbery and it needs to be defeated. owner Sternberg admitted it in the Rays stadium press conference when he said cars are five years ago. People will take rail to the stadium. A disgrace that tax dollars are being spent to sell it

Add new comment

columns
advertisement

Opinion Poll

Who did the better job choosing a lieutenant governor?
Older pollsResults
advertisement

Chatterbox

Live streaming of WBOB Talk Radio, a Sunshine State News Radio Partner.

advertisement
advertisement
advertisement