SSN on Facebook SSN on Twitter SSN on YouTube RSS Feed


Janet Cruz's Contradictions Are Eating up Her Campaign

October 4, 2018 - 6:00am
Janet Cruz
Janet Cruz

Inconsistencies dogging the Janet Cruz campaign for Florida Senate not only include key political issues but more fundamental representations, such as her name and address.

Cruz, a term-limited state representative, is challenging state Sen. Dana Young in Senate District,18.

Reciting one’s name and address is basic for most of us, starting in pre-K. But Cruz, age 62, has difficulty conveying a consistent response on both those fronts.

Which address is precisely her rental property or her true domicile, and at which address Cruz files for homestead exemption lies at the heart of her campaign’s most recent controversy.

Cruz claimed multiple homestead exemptions from 2004 through 2008, leading the Hillsborough County Property Appraiser to place a $32,000 lien for back taxes on an Empedrado Street home she purchased in 1983. That’s because Cruz had been living in a San Miguel Street home owned by her husband, while her then-29-year-old son was living in the Empedrado Street home.

The worst part: Cruz voted against a 2017 bill to increase the homestead exemption for all Floridians.

When Cruz first ran for the House in 2010, she dropped the name “Janet Rifkin,” her married name and the name she was known as. She explained she would run as “Janet Cruz” in the heavily Hispanic district “to avoid confusion.”

Such inconsistencies also match the Cruz legislative record and rhetoric. 

She filed to run for a seat on the Hillsborough County Commission, then changed her mind in February and decided to take on Young.

Publicly, Cruz said she was motivated to switch races because of the massacre of 17 students in Broward County. 

But when comprehensive gun control legislation came before the Florida Legislature, Cruz voted against it. The National Rifle Association opposed the bill and parents of the murder victims lobbied for it.

Young, who voted in favor, incurred the wrath of the NRA who, moments after the bill became law, filed a federal lawsuit against the State of Florida.

Then Cruz tried to sell herself as a friend of education. Debunking that claim was her open support of Susan Valdes, a former school board member who championed charter schools. 

When announcing she would run for Cruz’s open House seat, Valdes vowed not to accept campaign contributions from charter school interests. But Valdes reneged and, after it was reported by Tampa Bay Beat, Cruz rescinded her endorsement.

That was only eight days before the primary, after many mail ballots were submitted and early voting had begun. Valdes prevailed, much to the consternation of public school educators.

When Valdes ran for re-election to the school board in 2016, she accepted contributions from charter school interests. So it should have been no surprise to anyone, including Cruz, where her sympathies are.

With her poll numbers plummeting, Cruz recently blamed Young for the inadequate air conditioning in Hillsborough County schools. However, a 2016 study costing $818,000 advised the Hillsborough School District how to stop wasting taxpayer monies.

A whirlwind of confusion and contradiction surrounds Cruz. With only five weeks until the election, her only consistency is inconsistency. 

Jim Bleyer, a former reporter at the Orlando Sentinel and Tampa Tribune, writes the Tampa Bay Beat blog.


Too bad her most recent mailer featured parents who are voters, yet one cannot vote because she is a felon! Arrested for multiple crimes including gun possession, isn't Cruz against guns?? Way to find your supporters for your ads Janet!

Valdez was supported with contributions by charter school interests. Your flier is a non sequitur.

What a joke! Republican partisans don't give a damn about "inconsistencies"! Witness the truly bizarre Kavanaugh story histrionics and inconcsistencies ... or "The Religious Right" ... the supposed "Family Values" crowd ... "The Evangelicals" ... supporting a twice-divorced, thrice-married, serial adulterer, habitual liar, and non-church-going, no-values piece of work as President! Pffttt!

And this relates to this story how again?

Yeah Young is squeaky clean, NOT! Rep. Dana Young’s environmental record is as dirty as her campaign contributions, Her cozy relationship with big polluters like Mosaic and Big Sugar shows how out of touch she is with the everyday needs of Tampa’s working families. Her campaign photo from a mailer, shows her aiming what appears to be an assault-style rifle, with a large American flag and a copy of the Constitution in the background, in which she advertised her NRA "A" rating as Sen. Dana Young, R-Tampa. Meanwhile to protect that rating she missed votes on three key amendments during the Senate's session to debate legislation responding to the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting."Dana walked right out of the chamber as the vote was called, she will protect the NRA's priorities at all costs, including the safety of our school children."

When it comes to action, Young acted, Cruz did not. Shame on her for not supporting parents of dead children!

everyone knows the Dems did not vote for the act because they felt it did not go far enough. I'm an old school moderate Reagan Republican and I get that. Your angry diatribes supported by nonsense do not appeal to anyone except the radical nonsensical types supporting Spanky...

One part of your story is incorrect. Valdez did not accept or coordinate campaign support from the school choice political committee. We sent a mailer in support of Susan but we did not coordinate with her regarding that mailer. We supported Valdez because of her long-time support of empowering parents to be able to choose the school best for their child. Period. Cruz withdrawing her support of her 20-year long friend over something like a mailer, that wasn't even coordinated with Valdez, shows just want kind of person Cruz really is. Regarding the residency of Janet Cruz your story is factual! As a matter of fact, her now daughter-in-law, worked for Step Up at one time and the daughter-in-law lived in that West Tampa home. Janet never lived there. Instead she has lived in her South Tampa mansion with her husband which is out side of her House District. This is a violation of the state laws. Janet Cruz blames the legislature for the district's budget woes when it is the district's mismanagement of taxpayer dollars, as you noted, that have them now asking for a sales tax increase. To blame Dana Young for the lack of maintenance of our schools is ridiculous! It would be like me blaming Janet Cruz for the South Tampa street flooding after a summer rain.

Comments are now closed.

Live streaming of WBOB Talk Radio, a Sunshine State News Radio Partner.