advertisement

SSN on Facebook SSN on Twitter SSN on YouTube RSS Feed

9 Comments
Columns

How Entangled With Russia Is Trump?

August 1, 2016 - 7:00am

To gauge the opportunism and hypocrisy that define Donald Trump's Republican Party, consider this: Imagine the scalding rhetoric that would have boiled from the likes of Newt Gingrich, that Metternich of many green rooms, if Hillary Clinton had offhandedly undermined the collective security architecture of U.S. foreign policy since NATO was created in 1949.

Vladimir Putin's regime is saturating Europe with anti-Americanism, buying print and broadcast media, pliable journalists and other opinion leaders, and funding fringe political parties, think tanks and cultural institutions. (Putin is again following Hitler's playbook; read Alan Furst's historical novel "Mission to Paris," set in pre-war France.) Putin is etching with acid a picture of America as ignorant, narcissistic and, especially, unreliable. Trump validates every component of this indictment, even saying that the U.S. commitment to NATO's foundational principle -- an attack on one member is an attack on all -- is not categorical.

Gingrich, who is among the supposed savants who will steer Trump toward adulthood, flippantly dismisses Estonia, a NATO member contiguous to Putin's Russia and enduring its pressure, as "some place which is in the suburbs of St. Petersburg." Gingrich thereby echoes Neville Chamberlain's description, three days before Munich, of Hitler's pressure on Czechoslovakia as "a quarrel in a faraway country between people of whom we know nothing."

It would be fanciful to suggest that Trump read a book, but others should read Svetlana Alexievich's "Secondhand Time: The Last of the Soviets," an oral history of post-Soviet Russia, 1991 to 2012. A recurring theme is Russian nostalgia for the Soviet era: "We had a great empire -- stretching from sea to sea, from beyond the Arctic to the subtropics. Where is it now? It was defeated without a bomb."

Nostalgia coexists with Soviet-era memories like this: Twenty-seven people share an apartment with one kitchen and one bathroom, including a mother of a 5-year-old daughter and a childless woman. The mother is secretly informed against. Before being sent into the gulag for 17 years, she begged the childless woman to take care of her daughter, who comes to call the woman "Mama." After the real mother serves her sentence, under perestroika she sees her police file and recognizes her informant's signature -- her childless friend. The mother went home and hanged herself.

Putin's constituency of nostalgia, writes Alexievich, is in the grip of "the narcosis of old ideas" acquired when "the state had become their entire cosmos, blocking out everything else, even their own lives." She repeatedly records longings for the days before the eruption of ethnic hatreds to fill the void left by the melancholy, long withdrawing roar of socialist faith.

During one ethnic pogrom, "the youngest girl climbed a tree to escape ... so they shot at her like she was a little bird. It's hard to see at night, they couldn't get her for a long time. ... Finally, she fell at their feet."

Putin's supporters include those who, in the words of one of Alexievich's interlocutors, "feel like they were defeated twice over: The communist Idea was crushed," then Russia was looted by a feral crony capitalism. Putinism is bitter nostalgia on the march, and Putin is as interested in the U.S. presidential election as Trump and some of his aides are in Russian wealth. Read Franklin Foer's Slate essay "Putin's Puppet": 

"We shouldn't overstate Putin's efforts, which will hardly determine the outcome of the election. Still, we should think of the Trump campaign as the moral equivalent of Henry Wallace's communist-infiltrated campaign for president in 1948. ... A foreign power that wishes ill upon the United States has attached itself to a major presidential campaign." 

It is unclear whether any political idea leavens the avarice of Trump and some of his accomplices regarding today's tormented and dangerous Russia. Speculation about the nature and scale of Trump's financial entanglements with Putin and his associates is justified by Trump's refusal to release his personal and business tax information. Obviously he is hiding something, and probably more than merely embarrassing evidence that he has vastly exaggerated his net worth and charitableness.

In Wednesday's news conference, Trump said, "I have nothing to do with Russia." Donald Trump Jr. says, "Russians make up a pretty disproportionate cross-section of a lot of our assets. We see a lot of money pouring in from Russia."

Trump Sr. can end the speculation by providing information. If, however, he continues his tax information stonewall, it will be clear that he finds the speculation less damaging than the truth would be, which itself is important information.     

     

George Will's email address is georgewill@washpost.com.

(c) 2016, Washington Post Writers Group

    

Comments

I'm still laughing after reading just the first paragraph! It is time for George to get some therapy. Either that, or maybe we should take up a collection and send him on a vacation to the space station for a year. He is not really on this planet anyhow.

Judging by the above comments I think someone put Kool-aid in FL's water.....Wake up peeps...Trump is a charlatan and one of the finest con man that is alive today....

People seem to forget that Trump is under no obligation to release his taxes. Why should he? To give the wackos something else to attack him on. I wish George Will would go back to writing about baseball using big words. He was good at that. Have lost all respect for him.

Why continued inclusion of Trump Bashing in our Sunshine State News from the over-the-hill, irrelevant and senile Little Georgie? So what if he is the disgruntled mouthpiece of the Bush/Clinton/Obama cabal, let's move on.

compelling...

Will should hang himself, he writes this garbage ending with it's because Trump hasn't released his Tax information. Will, Like Mr. Trump said, 1st the IRS completes his Audit then he will release his tax returns. You're the commie George Will. You're the fool trying your best to pressure Trump for his tax returns so you can Ned pick and make crap up so you can make up more B.S. against him.

Well stated Fire! And, looking at his column picture, it appears he's already hung himself! George Will is no longer relevant and that fact is killing him! His words are more slanted than any set of Chinese eyes and he refuses to acknowledge the fact that Mr Trump has come this far in the election process.Of course, acknowledgement would mean he's been completely wrong since he began his negative writing in regards to Mr Trump, and I wonder if him being opposed to the candidate isn't somehow connected to the candidates' success. Thanks George! GO TRUMP!!

Entangled? Not at all. That is but a silly ploy to keep people from focusing on the fact that the DNC cheated its own members and rigged the primary to get Hillary nominated.

Entangled? Not at all. That is but a silly ploy to keep people from focusing on the fact that the DNC cheated its own members and rigged the primary to get Hillary nominated.

Comments are now closed.

columns
advertisement
advertisement

Chatterbox

advertisement
Live streaming of WBOB Talk Radio, a Sunshine State News Radio Partner.

advertisement
advertisement